Could ‘smart walls’ replace physical barriers at the US-Mexico border?

Nelson Balido is the principal and founder of Balido & Associates, a strategic business consultancy with federal government, trade, travel, stability and cross-border knowledge. Viewpoints are the author’s own.

6 months out from President Joe Biden’s inauguration, the upcoming of the border wall among Mexico and the United States is up in the air. There is not doubt that his stop-work govt order will impact the fate of our country’s southern border barrier and have extraordinary consequences for building firms presently in business with the federal government as properly as firms that hope to acquire federal contracts in the upcoming. 

The stop work purchase halts the generation of any new contracts for building of the actual physical border wall, and stops motion ahead on any phases of building that have not however been committed for or begun. 

Even so, that does not imply there will be zero alternatives to safe contracts with the federal government connected to our southern border. In fact, those alternatives may possibly simply just shift towards the far more technological know-how-concentrated clever wall that is dominating the discussion presently. 

Nelson Balido

Permission granted by Balido & Associates


The general idea that has been put forth by the new administration is that building of the border wall will be changed with a metaphorical wall consisting primarily of sensors that would provide as an intruder alert procedure, as opposed to a actual physical barrier. This clever wall would functionality as a big-scale stability procedure at the border line, in substitution of the brick-and-mortar wall that was remaining created prior to January. 

This usually means that whilst standard building firms may possibly drop out on alternatives, technological know-how firms have significantly to attain. 

What to take into consideration

In advance of any building begins on a clever wall border, there are many features that really should be diligently deemed in purchase to make certain the performance of its implementation. These include things like:

Inefficiency. Just one of the primary challenges with a actual physical border wall that will be an obstacle for any clever wall remedies is that actual physical limitations only slow down intruders, fairly than stop them from crossing fully. In areas where we presently have a actual physical border wall in put, the barrier presents border organizations far more time to react to the menace, but there is simply just absolutely nothing that is failsafe.

Place. The border wall is on U.S. soil. By virtue of the border wall’s locale, even if you had a person on the other facet, by legislation, the officer would have to go all-around the barrier and arrest the intruder, fairly than just transform them absent. In some methods, this produces far more headache and inefficiency than not having a wall at all. 

Level of tech sophistication. With a clever border wall, there are even far more hurdles to conquer in purchase to make certain the wall’s efficiency. A clever border wall would want to be designed up of many sensors to detect who and what is headed to the border. It is really important that these sensors are advanced ample to distinguish among animals and humans, and that they have a considerably variety in purchase to be in a position to detect intruders from as considerably off as feasible to give time for border enforcement to react and react. This kind of alert can be supplied by unattended ground sensors, LiDAR technological know-how, cameras, fiber lines buried in the ground and many other kinds of technological know-how.

But the bottom line is that there should be as significantly data as feasible transmitted by the “smart wall” so that enforcers know how to react and in what force.

Communication requirements. And lastly, topline communications are important to the progress of a clever border wall. A very big component of the locations alongside our southern border, and certainly the even greater and far more distant northern border, do not have any variety of communications. Border enforcers presently have to count on satellite telephones when they go out into some of these areas, but if there are no electrical power lines or options for telephone comms, then there is clearly no electrical power for a clever border wall, either. So, this offers a big possibility for firms who focus in electrical power and electrical power — specifically in distant areas — to acquire federal government contracts. Any clever wall set up or building plan will appear with tremendous electrical power requirements that the present-day border wall does not.

Even if electrical power is made in some of these areas that would be necessary to guidance the clever technological know-how of the border wall, mobile communications and radio communications will possible remain spotty at very best, and the technological know-how that would be required to aid communications in these very distant border areas is really high-priced for instance, the price of satellite cellular phone providers in these areas are astronomical, to a level where they are unsustainable because of to the costs associated. 

Even so, 1 of the up-and-coming technologies that can be employed to transport interaction indicators at a very significant level of speed, and at a price that is non-reoccurring, is Troposcatter technological know-how. Troposcatter is an emerging portable communications procedure that uses atmospheric particles to transport interaction waves. The procedure can be taken any place and transformed from a level-to-level procedure into a multi-level procedure depending on the scenarios. With Troposcatter technological know-how in the picture, the idea of a clever wall is significantly far more attainable mainly because comms could be paired with the clever border at a speedier, far more price-productive speed. 

As you can assemble, the stop-work on the southern border does not imply the conclude of agreement alternatives for personal firms. In fact, a clever border wall offers a myriad of alternatives for firms to acquire business from the federal federal government. There will be a want for many diverse technological providers, so if you own a organization or product or service that you believe that could profit the clever border wall, the time to get started positioning you at an benefit to acquire those contracts is now.